Determination of Mass Using a Beam Balance
1. Aim
To determine the mass of two different objects using a beam balance.
2. Apparatus Used
- Beam balance
- Standard masses (weights)
- Two objects of unknown mass
- Forceps (to handle weights)
- Weighing box
- Tissue paper/soft cloth (for cleaning)
3. Diagram
Fig 1: Schematic diagram of a beam balance showing its essential parts
4. Theory
A beam balance works on the principle of moments. It consists of a horizontal beam supported at the center by a fulcrum. The beam has two pans of equal mass suspended at equal distances from the fulcrum. When no masses are placed on either pan, the beam stays in a horizontal position.
When an object is placed on one pan, the beam tilts. To measure the mass of this object, standard masses are placed on the other pan until the beam becomes horizontal again. At equilibrium, the moments about the fulcrum are equal on both sides.
According to the principle of moments:
Since the distances \(d_1\) and \(d_2\) from the pans to the fulcrum are equal:
Therefore, the mass of the unknown object equals the sum of the standard masses placed on the other pan when the beam is horizontal.
5. Formula
The mass of the unknown object is given by:
Where:
- \(M_{object}\) = Mass of the object being measured
- \(\sum M_{standard}\) = Sum of the standard masses used to balance the beam
6. Procedure
- Setting up the balance:
- Place the beam balance on a level, stable surface.
- Check that the beam is horizontal when unloaded by adjusting the leveling screws if necessary.
- Ensure the pointer at the center of the beam aligns with the zero mark when unloaded.
- Measuring the first object:
- Place the first object on the left pan of the balance.
- Using forceps, carefully place standard masses on the right pan until the beam is balanced (pointer at zero).
- Start with larger masses and progressively add smaller ones as needed.
- Note the total mass of the standard weights used.
- Measuring the second object:
- Remove the first object and all standard masses.
- Check that the unloaded balance returns to equilibrium.
- Place the second object on the left pan.
- Repeat the balancing process with standard masses.
- Note the total mass of the standard weights used.
- Repeated measurements:
- Repeat the measurement for each object two more times.
- Calculate the average mass for each object.
7. Observation Table
Object | Trial | Mass of Standard Weights (g) | Average Mass (g) |
---|---|---|---|
Object 1 | 1 | ____________ | ____________ |
2 | ____________ | ||
3 | ____________ | ||
Object 2 | 1 | ____________ | ____________ |
2 | ____________ | ||
3 | ____________ |
8. Calculations
For each object, calculate the average mass from the three trials:
Where \(m_1\), \(m_2\), and \(m_3\) are the masses measured in trials 1, 2, and 3 respectively.
Example Calculation:
Suppose for Object 1, the masses measured in the three trials are:
- Trial 1: 45.5 g
- Trial 2: 45.7 g
- Trial 3: 45.6 g
The average mass would be:
9. Result
The masses of the two objects as determined using the beam balance are:
- Mass of Object 1: ____________ g
- Mass of Object 2: ____________ g
10. Precautions
- Ensure the balance is placed on a level, stable surface.
- Check that the balance is properly adjusted and reads zero when unloaded.
- Handle the weights with forceps to prevent contamination from oils on fingers.
- Place weights gently on the pan to avoid damaging the balance.
- Add or remove weights only when the balance is arrested (if it has an arresting mechanism).
- Avoid air currents around the balance during measurements.
- Make sure the object being weighed is clean and dry.
- Return all weights to their proper places in the weight box after use.
- Record readings only after the balance has come to a complete rest.
11. Sources of Error
- Instrumental Errors:
- Unequal arm lengths of the balance
- Inaccuracy in the standard masses
- Friction at the knife edges or fulcrum
- Observational Errors:
- Parallax error in reading the pointer position
- Misjudging when the beam is perfectly horizontal
- Environmental Errors:
- Air currents affecting the balance
- Temperature variations causing expansion/contraction of the balance parts
- Vibrations from surroundings
- Procedural Errors:
- Improper handling of weights
- Dust or fingerprints on the weights or objects
- Electrostatic charges on the object or balance
12. Viva Voice Questions
Q1: What is the principle behind the working of a beam balance?
A beam balance works on the principle of moments. When the beam is balanced, the moments of forces on both sides of the fulcrum are equal. Since the pans are at equal distances from the fulcrum, the weights on both pans must be equal for the beam to be horizontal.
Q2: Why is a beam balance more accurate than a spring balance?
A beam balance is more accurate because:
- It operates on the principle of comparison rather than absolute measurement
- It is not affected by variations in the gravitational field strength
- It doesn't suffer from elastic fatigue like springs do
- It has higher sensitivity for small mass differences
Q3: What is the least count of the beam balance used in this experiment?
The least count of a typical laboratory beam balance is 0.1 g or 0.01 g, depending on the quality and precision of the balance. The least count represents the smallest mass that can be measured accurately.
Q4: Why should weights be handled with forceps?
Weights should be handled with forceps to prevent:
- Contamination with oils, moisture, or dirt from fingers
- Corrosion due to acids in skin oils
- Changes in mass due to added material
- Damage to the calibrated surface of the weights
Q5: How does the sensitivity of a beam balance depend on the beam length?
The sensitivity of a beam balance increases with the length of the beam. Mathematically, for a small change in mass \(\Delta m\), the angular deviation \(\Delta \theta\) is given by:
Where \(L\) is the length of the beam arm and \(I\) is the moment of inertia of the beam. A longer beam causes a larger angular deflection for the same mass difference, making it easier to detect small mass variations.
Q6: What would happen if the arms of the beam balance were not equal?
If the arms of the beam balance were not equal, the balance would not give accurate measurements. According to the principle of moments:
With unequal arms (\(d_1 \neq d_2\)), the mass of the object (\(m_1\)) would not equal the mass of the standard weights (\(m_2\)) when the beam is balanced, leading to systematic errors in measurement.
Q7: How would you determine the zero error of a beam balance?
To determine the zero error of a beam balance:
- Ensure the balance is on a level surface
- Clean the pans and adjust the leveling screws
- Release the beam (if it has an arresting mechanism)
- Observe the position of the pointer when no weights are on either pan
- If the pointer doesn't align with the zero mark, note the deviation as the zero error
This error should be added or subtracted from subsequent measurements depending on whether the deviation is to the left or right of zero.
Q8: Why is it important to wait for the oscillations to stop before taking a reading?
It's important to wait for oscillations to stop before taking a reading because:
- The true equilibrium position can only be determined when the beam is stationary
- Reading during oscillation can lead to errors as the pointer moves back and forth
- The mean position during oscillation may not represent the true balance point due to damping effects
- Consistent protocol ensures reproducibility of measurements